Winning the Ballon d’Or with a striker is easy on FM. What about with a goalkeeper? That was the challenge one player set himself on FM24, and the result is one of the wildest sagas to hit r/footballmanagergames in 2026. Goalkeeper Matthias Santiago of Palermo won the Ballon d’Or nine times, scored 297 goals and signed off at 40 with his last award collected after retiring.

Santiago s nine Ballons d Or at Palermo (Image: Time_Fragments24h)
An experiment that lasted 32 seasons
The author, Time_Fragments24h, started with a simple idea: prove a goalkeeper could win the Ballon d’Or. To his surprise, Santiago did it at just 19, and he shared that on Reddit back in 2024. However, the experiment did not stop there. Instead, it turned into a 32-season Palermo save, 25 of them with Santiago in the squad.
When he retired, the numbers were absurd: 1,215 games, 297 goals, 662 assists and 747 clean sheets. Of those goals, 73 came from free kicks and 221 from penalties. Finally, only three came from open play, all rebounds from corners.
How a goalkeeper wins the Ballon d’Or on FM
The secret was set pieces. Santiago took the corners, free kicks and penalties, and played as a sweeper keeper on attack, which gave him more key passes and ratings above 8. Also, the author picked him for his potential at free kicks and penalties, not his goalkeeping attributes. The defence did the rest until he improved.
However, the hardest part was something else: stopping the strikers from stealing the award. So the author rotated his forwards so that none of them became top scorer in the major competitions. At the same time, he always needed at least three strong players in the air, with 15 or more for jumping and heading, to turn Santiago’s corners into goals.
The civil war with Don Lorenzo
Along the way, a rival emerged at home. Don Lorenzo, a striker from the same academy, won seven Ballons d’Or in a row, from 2051 to 2057, with seasons of 40 to 100 goals. In other words, the author spent years in an impossible balancing act: he needed Lorenzo’s goals to win trophies, but not so many that Santiago missed out on the ceremony.
So it was only at 38 that Santiago won the award again. Then he wanted to retire at 39, but the manager talked him into one more year. In his last season he scored 15 goals and made 25 assists in 46 games and, already retired, received his ninth Ballon d’Or. Before that, though, he lost his final match 5-4 to Parma, a side built from Palermo’s own former youngsters.

Santiago s world records at the end of his career (Image: Time_Fragments24h)
The most “Football Manager” moment of all
The author treasures one match. In 2041, against Juventus, with the title on the line and the score level in the 92nd minute, a 21-year-old Santiago scored a free kick. That goal sent Palermo to a title play-off against Milan, which was settled on penalties. In the end, the Scudetto was won by the goalkeeper’s gloves.
In the comments, some brought up Rogério Ceni, the Brazilian goalkeeper famous for free kicks and penalties, and the author admitted he was the true inspiration. He also said the save took 40 days of game time and that he never moved to FM26.
Our take
It is the kind of challenge only Football Manager allows. On one hand, it is an almost scientific experiment, with tests, rules and a lot of patience. On the other hand, it has everything that makes a good story: an unlikely hero, a rival at home and a final act with a defeat and an award. If you are looking for an FM27 challenge, this could be the inspiration.
What about you, have you ever tried something this crazy in a save?
Sources
- r/footballmanagergames, 28 October 2026
- r/footballmanagergames, Santiago’s first Ballon d’Or, 2024
Read also

